Has Apple Defined a New Medium, Again?

January 20, 2012

Apple announced new tools to cre­ate and view iBooks on the iPad, and a new dis­tri­b­u­tion chan­nel for dig­i­tal text­books. In doing so Apple ignited a firestorm of debate on the sub­ject of dig­i­tal books, and the future of the pub­lish­ing indus­try, book dis­tri­b­u­tion, and likely con­sumer con­sump­tion pat­terns. More impor­tantly, they set the stage for what we will some­day rec­og­nize as a new medium, a new form of con­tent in its own right.

And mean­while Apple is doing so at a time when the pub­lish­ing indus­try is at risk, with out­moded busi­ness mod­els, under attack on mul­ti­ple fronts.

More Than Just Textbooks

Apple posi­tioned their Jan­u­ary 19 announce­ment as an edu­ca­tion event, with the aim of rev­o­lu­tion­iz­ing the text­book pub­lish­ing indus­try. Accord­ing to the Wall Street Jour­nal, only 6% of text­books are deliv­ered today in dig­i­tal form, fore­casted to reach 50% by 2020. That’s a big tar­get in its own right, but I’d guess Apple’s unspo­ken aspi­ra­tions are even broader…

Well beyond what we think of as “books”

Years from now, we’ll look back at this moment and real­ize that Apple lit a fire, fuel­ing a new medium, one still to be named.

What Apple has in mind is not just a book or a text­book ren­dered dig­i­tally on an iPad. Their vision for this new type of con­tent goes well beyond dig­i­tal books, enhanced ebooks, or what­ever labels we use today.

Their vision mashes up ele­ments of movies, games, ani­ma­tions and dynamic mod­els, inter­ac­tiv­ity,  hyper­link­ing and non­lin­ear nav­i­ga­tion — key enhance­ments to the core ele­ments of sto­ry­telling, nar­ra­tive flow, design, lay­out, etc. Here are some of the core ele­ments that will drive our under­stand­ing of this new medium, as I see it.

Beyond the Book

— Source, Chris­tine Thomp­son, Inform­ing Arts ©2012

Text­books First, But Not Last

I sus­pect Apple chose the text­book as the ini­tial tar­get for rein­ven­tion because the lim­i­ta­tions of a print-based medium for multi-dimensional, com­plex or time-sensitive sub­jects are so well under­stood. Apple’s long expe­ri­ence at sell­ing to and sup­port­ing edu­ca­tional insti­tu­tions affords the com­pany unique insights into what works, and what’s bro­ken, when it comes to 21st cen­tury education.

The text­book pub­lish­ing indus­try is huge, and can help finance the tri­als that will even­tu­ally shape the win­ning char­ac­ter­is­tics of this new emerg­ing medium. In North Amer­ica alone the tra­di­tional text­book pub­lish­ing indus­try gen­er­ates $12–14 bil­lion annu­ally, accord­ing to one expert (for a more con­ser­v­a­tive assump­tion: > $4 bil­lion in 2011 text­book sales, accord­ing to the WSJ today; $8 bil­lion in 2010 accord­ing to For­rester. Clearly no one agrees on the def­i­n­i­tion of the indus­try, but it’s huge.)

From Apple’s per­spec­tive (as a mas­ter of dis­rup­tive inno­va­tions), the edu­ca­tional pub­lish­ing indus­try must be a sit­ting duck, ripe for transformation.

“We are edu­cat­ing peo­ple today in the same way as we did when there was 1% as much knowledge.”

– Danny Hillis, The Econ­o­mist, March 22, 2001

That said Apple is will­ing to be a part­ner, not just a dis­rupter. Apple announced that it plans to part­ner with edu­ca­tors and pub­lish­ers (reported by the Wall Street Jour­nal today). When this part­ner­ship is pro­duc­tive, those who embrace change and can envi­sion a new medium should profit enormously.

This New Medium Requires New Tal­ents & Specialties

What will emerge is a new form of multi-faceted con­tent. This new medium will require con­tri­bu­tions from many spe­cial­ties, such as:

  • Pho­tog­ra­phers, video­g­ra­phers, musi­cians, producers
  • Design­ers, illus­tra­tors, animators
  • Art/creative direc­tors for the ensem­ble as a whole
  • Game devel­op­ers — peo­ple who know how to incor­po­rate game mechan­ics (“gam­i­fi­ca­tion”) within designed experiences
  • User expe­ri­ence and inter­ac­tion designers
  • Usabil­ity testers
  • Web devel­op­ers and pro­duc­ers (HTML5 and CSS3 experts), scripters and coders
  • Infor­ma­tion archi­tects, tax­on­omy and tag­ging specialists

And of course, the usual:

  • Writ­ers and copy­writ­ers (as well as trans­la­tors for books with global appeal)
  • Edi­tors
  • Fact check­ers
  • Tal­ent spot­ters (acqui­si­tion experts)

On the strate­gic level this new medium will require vision­ar­ies, risk tak­ing pio­neers, game chang­ers and oth­ers whose per­son­al­i­ties are prob­a­bly abhor­rent to the tra­di­tional pub­lish­ing world.

Not to men­tion new mod­els for brand build­ing, social media inter­ac­tions with con­sumers, and new forms of mar­ket­ing. But that’s a whole dif­fer­ent sub­ject in its own right.

[Dis­clo­sure: I played a key role in Apple’s early days of dig­i­tal pub­lish­ing, but have had no involve­ment in their cur­rent activ­i­ties. The opin­ions described here are my own, based on inter­pre­ta­tions of what I’ve read and heard over the Web.]

Print Friendly

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Bill Forquer January 24, 2012 at 6:49 AM

Nice thinking Christine. I get excited thinking about this as Apple’s beginning to disrupt book publishing – lots of history to suggest you are correct.

One other core element, maybe in the book or the layered application on top of the book, is some disruptive notion of a classroom learning environment that personalizes the experience based on role of teacher or students and can dynamically transform the “beyond the book” rich media to support quality interactions regardless of being in the same/different time/space as classmates.

Reply

Christine Thompson January 24, 2012 at 8:26 AM

Thanks for the feedback, Bill. I was there when Apple disrupted publishing the first time, and I must say, this feels like a similar playbook...

I agree with your notion that an added layer of capability could really introduce rich dynamics into the classroom, or even make the textbook’s content way more comprehensible or memorable. I can imagine the impact of tailoring elements of the text based on the needs of the class as a whole, or even for defined niche groups with special needs.

As a very basic example: in a mixed classroom of English and Spanish speakers, everyone gets the same “next gen textbook” downloaded to their iPad — except they get to choose English or Spanish text.

Or in a class about atmospheric science, the teacher adapts the text to her class theme or locality; for example, choosing to “embed” or hyperlink to a series of weather maps and forecast data that are very focused on the region where her students live. Students in Washington would see a real focus on the weather coming off the Pacific and the impact of ocean currents; those in Ohio would see an emphasis on weather patterns based on the interaction of systems coming across the North American continent, as well as the causes of “Lake Effect.”

On a different note, here’s my preliminary take based on one day’s usage of Apple’s new authoring tool.

iBook Author is wonderfully simple and elegant, a true joy to use for simple writing and assembly of media components. But it is too simplistic to afford conditional logic that swaps out text or components based on tagging and scripting. In its current form it lacks the capabilities that would power the kinds of capabilities you outline in your comment. You can’t even do simple things like prevent an overuse of hyphenation in the same paragraph!

But Apple has a long history of introducing tools like iBook Author to serve as exemplars — and a cattle prod, to provoke the software industry to create what’s really needed. In the early days of the Mac, Apple seeded multiple product categories that later on, companies like Microsoft and Adobe exploited to great commercial advantage.

I have to imagine that some company will create a more powerful authoring environment that offers the capabilities now lacking in iBook Author. If Adobe were still creating innovative tools (instead of just acquiring companies), we might expect such an authoring platform to come from them. Instead we’ll have to wait for some newcomer to create the must-have authoring platform for next gen textbooks.

A day with Apple’s iBook Author reminds you of the power of simplicity — and the frustration that comes with using a tool with such limited capabilities, when you keep encountering use cases that Apple chose to ignore…

Reply

Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Previous post:

Next post: